Skip to main content

As Cracker Barrel recently learned the hard way, it can be a costly mistake when your brand identity and brand image aren’t aligned. Over the summer, the restaurant chain launched a new, modernized logo, but that identity flew in the face of the brand image its customers knew and loved. The marketing team was quickly reminded that while the words may sound interchangeable, it’s important to understand what they mean, how they’re perceived and the value in nurturing both to build a powerful, resilient and cohesive brand.

What is Brand Identity? 

Your brand identity is the intentional, controlled expression of who you are, what you stand for and what you promise. Think of it as your company’s DNA and carefully crafted public persona.

Brand identity encompasses both tangible elements like visual identity and products or services, as well intangibles like messaging and values. Visual identity includes your logo, color palette, typography, and imagery that conveys professionalism and personality to your customers. The functionality of your products or services, including packaging and the user experience, show your customers the quality you offer and your attention to detail. Messaging and taglines exude your brand’s tone of voice and define what makes you different. Another important aspect are your core values, mission and vision. Behaving in a way that is consist with those shows stakeholders you are authentic and committed to a purpose. A styleguide can capture all these elements and be a handy reference for maintaining continuity across different materials and touchpoints. 

Having a strong brand identity is foundational for business because it offers four key advantages: 

  • Differentiation: It clearly separates you from competitors in a crowded marketplace.
  • Consistency: It ensures a uniform experience, which builds recognition and trust.
  • Internal Alignment: It gives employees a clear vision, mission and set of values to rally behind, which in turn improves service delivery.
  • Value: A well-defined identity supports premium pricing and long-term brand equity.

What is Brand Image?

Your brand image is the collective, external perception customers and the general public have of your company. It is formed naturally through experiences and exposure to your brand, each of which creates emotional and psychological associations. 

Brand image can be trickier to control than brand identity because it is shaped by factors that are outside of your direct control. A customer’s experience will make an impact, from the quality of customer service to the ease of use of products or their performance. Living up to their expectations on these experiences will convey reliability, value and trustworthiness. The media also can sway perceptions that affect your reputation, public sentiment and market standing. While marketing campaigns are carefully designed and planned, how they hit with audiences is out of your hands. Once your media is deployed, customers will decide if they find it relevant, aspirational and socially responsible. 

Brand image lives in the mind of consumers, and it can change on a dime from a single positive or negative experience. Businesses that curate a positive brand image can benefit in multiple ways.

  • Customer Loyalty and Advocacy: A strong, positive image fosters emotional connections, leading to repeat business and customers who champion your brand.
  • Purchase Decisions: It provides a strong competitive advantage, as consumers often choose brands they perceive positively, even over lower-priced alternatives.
  • Resilience in Crisis: A strong reputation provides a buffer during challenging times, as the public is more likely to give a trusted brand the benefit of the doubt.
  • Talent Attraction: People want to work for and partner with brands that are highly regarded.

Alignment Is Everything

The gap between your brand identity and your brand image is your greatest risk, but also your biggest opportunity. When what you strive to be is aligned with what people think you are, you’ve created a powerful, cohesive brand. But when brandy identity and image are misaligned, the disconnect can shatter customer trust and cause financial or reputational damage. 

Your primary goal as a business isn’t just to design a beautiful identity, but to consistently deliver on the promise of that identity across every single touchpoint. Only through consistent action, genuine value delivery, and authentic communication can you bridge the gap and cultivate a positive brand image that aligns perfectly with your intended identity.Need help creating a brand identity that truly represents your company or shifting perceptions of your image? Contact us today to find out how our branding experts can get you where you want to be.

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.